Warren & Migliaccio, L.L.P.

Texas Family, Estate and Debt Relief Attorneys

Call For A Free Consultation (888) 584-9614
  • Our Team
    • Gary Warren
    • Christopher Migliaccio
    • Jonathan Frederick
    • Dan Varkey
    • Traci Diamond
    • Sabah Hafiz
    • David Lane
    • Morgan Gill
    • Brandon Beuerlein
    • MaDonna Harmina
  • Bankruptcy
    • Why Meet with Us?
    • Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
      • How to File Chapter 7 Bankruptcy in Texas
    • Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
    • Debt Resolution
    • Benefits of Bankruptcy
      • Stop Creditor Harrassment
      • Keep Your Property
      • Stop Foreclosure
      • Eliminate Credit Card Debt
      • Rebuild Your Credit
    • Bankruptcy Myths Debunked
    • Creditor Harassment
    • Tax Debt
    • What is a Wage Garnishment?
    • Bankruptcy Video Center
    • FREE Bankruptcy E-Book
  • Debt Lawsuits
    • Being Sued by Debt Collector? What you need to Know.
    • What to do when you are being sued by Credit Card Company
    • Is it possible to be Judgment Proof?
  • Divorce
    • Divorce Timeline and Roadmap
    • Contested Divorce
    • High Net Worth Divorce
    • High Conflict Divorce
    • Spousal Maintenance and Support
    • Post-Divorce Modifications
    • Military Divorce
    • FREE Divorce E-Book
  • Child Custody
    • Types of Child Custody in Texas
    • Child Support Modifications & Enforcements
    • Child Support: The Details You Should Know
    • Texas Standard Possession Order
    • Texas Child Custody Calendar
    • Right of First Refusal
  • Estate Planning
    • Our Services
    • How it Works- Your Client Journey
    • Estate Plan Express
    • Wills
    • Revocable Living Trusts
      • 9 Reasons You Need a Revocable Living Trust in Texas
      • Making and Funding a Living Trust in Texas
    • Is It Time to Update Your Estate Plan?
    • Dying without a Will
  • Estate Plan Express
    • Estate Plan Express: Get an Attorney Drafted Will Online in Texas
    • Our Levels of Texas Estate Planning Services
  • Blog
    • Articles
    • FAQs
      • How to create a Skype Account for Virtual Video Meetings
      • Get Tax Transcripts or Tax Returns
      • Get Your Free Credit Report
  • Next Steps
    • Contact Us
    • Client Testimonials
    • Make a Payment
    • Camp Lejuene Victim Support
      • How we can help
      • Top 5 Questions and Answers About the Camp Lejeune Lawsuits
      • Symptoms of Water Contamination
You are here: Home / Bankruptcy / Chapter 7 Bankruptcy / Second Circuit Upholds $2.5 Million Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Settlement Amid Creditor Dispute| Warren & Migliaccio
Second Circuit Upholds .5 Million Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Settlement Amid Creditor Dispute| Warren & Migliaccio

Second Circuit Upholds $2.5 Million Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Settlement Amid Creditor Dispute| Warren & Migliaccio

August 17, 2024
Written by Christopher Migliaccio | Last updated on August 17, 2024

Table of Contents

Toggle
  • A New York Bankruptcy Court Correctly Refused to Overturn the Approval of a $2.5 Million Settlement
  • Two-Judge Panel Supports District Judge’s Decision
  • No Abuse of Discretion by the Bankruptcy Court
  • Background on the Stadtmauers’ Lawsuit
  • Court’s Rejection of Stadtmauers’ Argument
  • Settlement Approval Not a Final Disposition
  • Fraudulent Conveyance and Alter-Ego Claims Considered “General”
  • District Court’s Decision on the Better Offer
  • Trustee’s Acceptance of a Counteroffer
  • Comparison of Settlement Offers
  • Conclusion on Bankruptcy Court’s Discretion
  • Mark Nordlicht’s Conviction and Sentencing
  • Judges Involved in the Second Circuit Ruling
  • Responses from Legal Counsel
  • Legal Representation in the Case
  • Case Information

A New York Bankruptcy Court Correctly Refused to Overturn the Approval of a $2.5 Million Settlement

A New York bankruptcy court correctly refused to overturn the approval of a $2.5 million settlement in the bankruptcy of a founder of defunct hedge fund Platinum Partners, the Second Circuit ruled Thursday, finding that the approved deal was superior to an alternative offer.

Two-Judge Panel Supports District Judge’s Decision

In a 63-page opinion, a two-judge panel said U.S. District Judge Kenneth Karas got it right when he rejected Richard and Marisa Stadtmauer’s appeal of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court’s acceptance of the settlement rather than the one they proposed. The panel explained that the Stadtmauers didn’t have any secured or priority claims against Platinum co-founder Mark Nordlicht that overruled the settlement and that the district judge didn’t err in choosing the best offer.

No Abuse of Discretion by the Bankruptcy Court

“The bankruptcy court did not abuse its discretion in concluding that the Stadtmauers’ asserted liens were in bona fide dispute and therefore did not bar the trustee from settling the Stadtmauers’ asserted claims pursuant to Bankruptcy Code,” the panel wrote.

Background on the Stadtmauers’ Lawsuit

According to the opinion, before Nordlicht entered Chapter 7 bankruptcy in 2020, the Stadtmauers filed a lawsuit in a New York state court accusing Nordlicht of hiding his assets in shell companies to avoid paying back his debts, and they asked the state court to award them valid liens on two of the founder’s real estate holdings. They argued that the state court did so and said that if they prevailed on their fraudulent conveyance claims in state court, those liens guaranteed them secured property rights to enforce that the bankruptcy trustee’s authority could not settle.

Court’s Rejection of Stadtmauers’ Argument

However, the panel didn’t buy their argument. Firstly, it pointed out that the state court never granted them valid judicial liens because “the validity of the liens is in dispute.”

Settlement Approval Not a Final Disposition

“As the bankruptcy court repeatedly emphasized, the approval of the settlement at the sale hearing was not a final disposition of the claims against the estate,” the panel added. “Accordingly, the Stadtmauers’ assertion that their lien secures their claims and gives them priority over the unsecured creditors is, indeed, ‘yet [to be] fully resolved.'”

Fraudulent Conveyance and Alter-Ego Claims Considered “General”

Even if the liens are valid, the opinion said the Stadtmauers’ fraudulent conveyance and alter-ego claims — which allege the founder’s fraud against the Stadtmauers and all of his creditors and business partners — are “general,” not “personal,” and therefore the claims are still the property of the bankruptcy estate that can be settled.

District Court’s Decision on the Better Offer

Additionally, the opinion said the district court correctly decided that the trustee chose the better offer to settle compared to the Stadtmauers’ offer.

Trustee’s Acceptance of a Counteroffer

The trustee ultimately accepted a counteroffer from the state court defendants for $2.5 million, plus another $2.5 million in indemnification if the Stadtmauers succeeded in asserting their liens.

Comparison of Settlement Offers

Compared to the Stadtmauers’ offer of $2 million and dropping liens they had asserted against the estate, the opinion concluded that the approved settlement “was superior because under its terms, [Mark Nordlicht’s mother] Barbara Nordlicht (1) indemnified the $2.5 million payment and (2) would reimburse the estate for any legal fees incurred from defending against the Stadtmauers’ asserted legal claims.”

Conclusion on Bankruptcy Court’s Discretion

“The bankruptcy court did not abuse its discretion in finding that the settlement’s future benefits outweighed the possibility that the Stadtmauers may succeed in their litigation,” the panel added.

Mark Nordlicht’s Conviction and Sentencing

Mark Nordlicht was convicted in July 2019, along with former co-chief investment officer David Levy, of a purported $70 million fraud on the bondholders of the Platinum portfolio company Black Elk Energy, an oil and gas company. Nordlicht avoided imprisonment in January when U.S. District Judge Brian Cogan sentenced him to two years of probation, with six months of the time to be served in home confinement, and ordered him to pay a $5,000 fine.

Judges Involved in the Second Circuit Ruling

U.S. Circuit Judges Debra Ann Livingston and Robert D. Sack sat on the panel for the Second Circuit. U.S. Circuit Judge Rosemary S. Pooler was originally on the panel but died in August 2023.

Responses from Legal Counsel

Counsel for the Stadtmauers declined to comment Thursday.

Counsel for Nordlicht did not immediately respond to a request for comment., and counsel for the other appellees declined to comment Thursday.

Legal Representation in the Case

The Stadtmauers are represented by Nathaniel J. Kritzer of Steptoe LLP.

The Chapter 7 trustee is represented by Salvatore LaMonica and Jacqulyn S. Loftin of LaMonica Herbst & Maniscalco LLP.

Nordlicht is represented by Scott Krinsky of Backenroth Frankel & Krinsky LLP.

The other appellees are represented by Michael Levine of Levine & Associates PC and Sari E. Kolatch of Cohen Tauber Spievack & Wagner PC.

Case Information

The case is In re: Mark A. Nordlicht, case number 22-1223, in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit.

(source)

Categories: Chapter 13 Bankruptcy, Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Tagged: Bankruptcy Tag

Get Help Now!

Schedule a Free Consultation

If you need to speak with an attorney at Warren & Migliaccio, L.L.P.  submit our contact form below or call (888) 584-9614 to schedule a free consultation.

Nav

  • Collin County & Dallas Bankruptcy Attorneys: Chapter 7 Solutions for DFW
  • Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Attorney in Dallas
  • Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Lawyer in Dallas
  • Child Custody Attorneys in Dallas and North Texas
  • Child Support
  • Divorce Attorney in Dallas & Collin County – Serving All of DFW and North Texas
  • Family Law
  • Spousal Support
  • Personal Injury
Christopher Migliaccio, attorney in Dallas, Texas
About the Author

Christopher Migliaccio is an attorney and a Co-Founding Partner of the law firm of Warren & Migliaccio, L.L.P. Chris is a native of New Jersey and landed in Texas after graduating from the Thomas M. Cooley School of Law in Lansing, Michigan. Chris has experience with personal bankruptcy, estate planning, family law, divorce, child custody, debt relief lawsuits, and personal injury. If you have any questions about this article, you can contact Chris by clicking here.

Connect With Us

facebook logo twitter logo youtube logo instagram logo


More Resources
Blog
Articles
PaymentPortal

Schedule Now
(888) 584-9614

Next Steps

  • Contact Us
  • Testimonials
  • Make A Payment
  • Blog
  • Articles
  • FAQs

Pick a Topic and Empower Yourself

  • Bankruptcy
  • Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
  • Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
  • Child Custody
  • Child Support
  • Estate Planning
  • Divorce
  • Divorce & Your Children
  • Family Law
  • Stop Foreclosure
  • Spousal Support
  • Auto Accidents
HomeDisclaimerPrivacy PolicyTerms of UseContact UsSite Map
© 2025 Warren & Migliaccio, L.L.P. All Rights Reserved